Flashback Episode — God’s Adoption Perk: Matthew 17:24-27

As we continue our way through the second half of Matthew’s gospel, we come to an event that only Matthew includes, and this is an event that doesn’t seem to have any resolution, except that this event likely happens exactly as Jesus describes. After all, Jesus describes other events in detail and they happen just as Jesus predicted, so there is no reason in my mind to doubt that this event happened exactly the way Jesus predicted it.

However, in this event, we also see a parallel to one of the biggest themes in the entire Bible, and when I saw this theme in this event, I have a hard time unseeing it.

Let’s read what happened and discover what this short passage teaches us about God’s character. Our passage is found in Matthew’s gospel, chapter 17, and we will be reading from the New Century Version of the Bible. Starting in verse 24, Matthew tells us that:

²⁴ When Jesus and his followers came to Capernaum, the men who collected the Temple tax came to Peter. They asked, “Does your teacher pay the Temple tax?”

²⁵ Peter answered, “Yes, Jesus pays the tax.”

Peter went into the house, but before he could speak, Jesus said to him, “What do you think? The kings of the earth collect different kinds of taxes. But who pays the taxes—the king’s children or others?”

²⁶ Peter answered, “Other people pay the taxes.”

Jesus said to Peter, “Then the children of the king don’t have to pay taxes. ²⁷ But we don’t want to upset these tax collectors. So go to the lake and fish. After you catch the first fish, open its mouth and you will find a coin. Take that coin and give it to the tax collectors for you and me.”

With this verse, our event ends. We are left to conclude that this event happened exactly as Jesus described to Peter. However, in this event, I find it fascinating that when these tax collectors come, they ask Peter whether Jesus pays the temple tax. This is interesting in my mind because these tax collectors don’t ask Peter if he pays the tax or if any of the other disciples pay the tax.

This got me thinking about what this tax was. A quick search located the verses talking about the Temple Tax in the book of Exodus, chapter 30. Verses 12-14 describe this tax saying: “When you take a census of the Israelites, each person must pay the Lord a ransom for his life when he is counted. Then no plague will happen to them when they are counted. As each person is counted, he must give one-fifth of an ounce of silver using the standard weight of the holy place. This one-fifth of an ounce of silver is a contribution to the Lord. Everyone counted who is at least 20 years old must give this contribution to the Lord.”

From this reference in the Old Testament, and from how these tax collectors frame their question to Peter, we see a strong clue that all of Jesus’ disciples looked like they were less than 20 years old, and with the exception of Peter, who might have looked younger, they all were less than 20. Peter likely was older than 20, because Jesus tells Peter to use what he catches with the fish to pay the tax for the two of them.

However, while we have this huge clue about the disciples’ ages hidden in the details of this event, what is more amazing are the details surrounding who actually pays the temple tax in this event. When we ask ourselves the question about where the coin came from to pay the tax, we discover something amazing.

On first glance, it appeared as though Peter paid the temple tax, but the coin Peter used was not Peter’s. The coin Peter used wasn’t even Jesus’ or from the money that had been gifted or given to Jesus and His disciples. Instead, the coin came to Peter in the most unusual way.

For the events to happen just like Jesus described, the only possible explanation is that God’s hand was clearly at work in this event. Either God created a coin in the fish’s mouth when Peter hooked it, or an angel directed a coin to fall into the water, a fish to catch the coin in its mouth, and then direct that fish to Peter’s hook at the exact point in time that Peter was down at the lake fishing. All while keeping the other fish away so that this would be the first fish Peter caught.

Everything in this event speaks to God being the ultimate source of the coin used to pay the temple tax. This means that in this event, God pays His own tax. While I don’t know if Jesus would have paid the tax if these tax collectors had asked Him directly, but because they ask Peter, and because Peter promises before thinking, Jesus steps in with a solution.

This event has a huge theme tucked within it that tells us God is willing to help us when we have messed up and made mistakes. While Jesus’ mission to earth guarantees and pays for everything we need for a future life in Heaven, this event with the fish and the temple tax teach us that God is even willing to help us when we mess up in this life and over promise when we can only under-deliver. God is interested in our lives on this earth, and He is willing to help us save face by providing us a way out.

The Temple Tax collectors likely had no idea where the coin came from, and even if Peter had told them, they probably wouldn’t have believed him. However, in this event, God pays His own tax, and this tax is supposed to be paid by others. When we are adopted into God’s family, He pays the spiritual tax that we owe, and He helps us leave our past behind as we begin a new life with Him. Our life in God’s family can begin today, and our life in God’s family extends into eternity!

As we come to the end of another podcast episode, here are the challenges I will leave you with:

As I always challenge you to do, intentionally seek God first and accept the gift of adoption into His family. Place your faith, hope, trust, and belief in Jesus and thank Jesus for everything He has blessed us with through what He did for us and through what He is still doing for us in heaven. Be sure to thank God for paying the tax that we owe, and thank Him for taking an interest in our lives.

Also, continue praying and studying the Bible for yourself to learn, grow, and discover what God is truly like. God the Father is not the mean, judgmental God that some people think He is. God the Father is a God who loves us so much that He paid the tax and debt we owed. Jesus’ death isn’t about forgiving us as much as it is actually paying the debt that we owed. We can be forgiven because Jesus paid our debt! Take this truth, and study it out for yourself through prayer and reading the pages of God’s Word. Discover a God who loves you more than you can imagine, and a God who wants to save you for eternity!

And as I end every set of challenges by saying in one way or another, never stop short of, back away from, chicken out of, or give up on where God wants to lead you to in your life with Him!